Isn't the Empty Chair the Symbolic Message Already? | Unpublished
Hello!

Unpublished Opinions

mcklee's picture
Markham, Ontario
About the author

Mimi Lee is one of the main organizers of Torontonian HongKongers Action Group , which the group has been organizing different events since June last year in Toronto to raise awareness and support the current pro-democracy movement in Hong Kong started by the extradition to China bill fiasco. Since 2012, she has been awakened by the Moral and National Education controversy in Hong Kong, and realized that Hong Kong has been going downhill for so many years since the handover in 1997. After the Umbrella Movement in 2014, it has encouraged her to do a lot more than just supporting Hong Kong, but actually involved in different initiatives raising awareness of the situation of Hong Kong.

 

Tags

Like it

Isn't the Empty Chair the Symbolic Message Already?

October 9, 2026

The announcement of the 2026 Nobel Peace Prize has brought renewed attention to the career of South African jurist Navanethem "Navi" Pillay. The Norwegian Nobel Committee recognized Pillay for her contributions to international law and human rights. Pillay previously served as United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights from 2008 to 2014. 

But awards often invite scrutiny alongside praise.

In the days following the announcement, critics revisited controversies from Pillay's tenure at the United Nations. Among them was her decision not to attend the 2010 Nobel Peace Prize ceremony honoring imprisoned Chinese dissident Liu Xiaobo. Critics argued then, and argue now, that her absence represented a missed opportunity to send a powerful signal in support of human rights in China. 

At the same time, critics have raised broader concerns about institutional conduct within the UN human-rights system during her tenure, including allegations involving the handling of dissidents and NGO accreditation processes. 

The contrast between these criticisms is striking. One concerns institutional behavior and administrative decisions. The other concerns attendance at a ceremony. Yet public debate often gravitates toward the latter.

Why?

Part of the answer may lie in the nature of symbolism itself. Symbolic moments are easy to understand. They produce headlines, photographs and memorable narratives. Institutional conduct is different. It is often buried in procedures, correspondence, committee decisions and bureaucratic processes that rarely capture public attention.

The story of Liu Xiaobo illustrates this tension particularly well.

In 2010, Liu was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize while serving an 11-year prison sentence in China for his democratic activism. Unable to attend the ceremony in Oslo, he was represented by an empty chair. The image quickly became one of the most recognizable symbols of political repression in the modern era. Pillay did not attend the ceremony. Her office explained that she remained in Geneva for Human Rights Day events focused on human-rights defenders and denied that the decision had been influenced by Chinese pressure. 

Many people found that explanation unsatisfactory. Some still do.

Yet sixteen years later, it is worth asking why this particular episode continues to carry such symbolic weight.

After all, the message had already been delivered.

The Nobel Peace Prize itself was a message.

The international media attention surrounding the award was a message.

The diplomatic controversy that followed was a message.

And above all, the empty chair was a message. 

None of this is meant to dismiss the importance of symbolism. Human-rights movements have long relied upon symbols to draw attention to injustice. Symbols preserve memory. Symbols communicate solidarity. Symbols can inspire action. Yet the persistence of this debate may reveal something else.

The United Nations is, by design, an institution whose influence often rests on persuasion, legitimacy and moral authority rather than direct enforcement power. It can investigate, document, advocate, condemn and convene. But when dealing with sovereign governments, especially powerful states, its ability to compel policy change is often limited. 

Perhaps that is why symbolic gestures occupy such a prominent place in international human-rights advocacy.

When tangible leverage is limited, symbolism becomes a form of action. Attendance at ceremonies, public statements, commemorations and diplomatic signals are invested with enormous significance because they are among the few tools available. Yet that reality also raises an uncomfortable question.

If symbolic acts are treated as instruments of change, how should their effectiveness be measured?

The Nobel Prize was a symbol.

The empty chair was a symbol.

Years of statements, resolutions, reports, campaigns and commemorations have all been symbols.

At what point do additional symbolic affirmations stop generating additional impact?

This question is particularly relevant when discussing authoritarian governments that have repeatedly demonstrated a willingness to absorb international criticism without materially altering their underlying policies. Critics may argue that every symbolic gesture matters. Perhaps it does. But it is equally reasonable to ask whether the accumulation of symbolic gestures should automatically be treated as evidence of political progress.

This brings us back to the criticisms of Navi Pillay. If one believes that the most serious questions surrounding her legacy concern institutional conduct at the United Nations, then the real debate should focus on actions, decisions and accountability. If one believes those allegations are unfounded, then the debate should focus on evidence.

Either way, it is worth asking why attendance at a ceremony continues to dominate the conversation. Public life often rewards symbolism because symbolism is visible. Institutions are harder to understand and even harder to explain. Yet it is institutions, not ceremonies, that ultimately shape outcomes. That observation does not diminish the significance of Liu Xiaobo's Nobel Prize.

Quite the opposite.

The empty chair remains one of the defining images of modern political repression precisely because it communicated so much with so little. It required no speech, no explanation and no additional endorsement.

If the empty chair became one of the defining symbols of political repression in the 21st century, what additional message remained unsent?



References